Question

  1. A, B and C are three people. One of them is a liar who always tells lies, another is a saint who always tells the truth, and the third is a switcher who sometimes tells the truth and sometimes lies. They make the following statements:

    A: I am the liar.
    B: A is the liar.
    C: I am not the liar.

    Who is the liar among A, B and C? Briefly explain your answer.

  2. P, Q and R are three more people, one a liar, one a saint, and the third a contrarian who tells a lie if he is the first to speak or if the preceding speaker told the truth, but otherwise tells the truth. They make the following statements:

    P: Q is the liar.
    Q: R is the liar.
    R: P is the liar.

    Who is the liar among P, Q and R? Briefly explain your answer.

  3. X, Y and Z are three more people, one a liar, one a switcher and one a contrarian. They make the following statements:

    X: Y is the liar.
    Y: Z is the liar.
    Z: X is the liar.
    X: Y is the liar.
    Y: X is the liar.

    Who is the liar among X, Y and Z? Briefly explain your answer.